Hillel: The Foundation for Jewish Campus Life - Logo and Link Home.
Search:     
navigation bar dropshadow.
spacer alignment.
spacer alignment.
Being Jewish and LGBT on Campus
May 18, 2007
Comments (34) | Add | E-mail this to a friend
 

A student attends the 2006 NUJLS conference.
A student attends the 2006 NUJLS conference at Wesleyan University.

When the Conservative Jewish movement voted in December 2006 to permit openly gay and lesbian students to become rabbis, three-quarters of the student body at the University of Judaism signed a letter of support that stated “as future rabbis, we feel bound by the tenets of halakhah and moved by the ethical challenges posed by our new scientific knowledge and modern understandings of sexual orientation.”

The vote signified a growing acceptance of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) students in the Jewish community and on college campuses.

“Today, heterosexual students are not ashamed to say they know and have friendships with LGBT adults and students,” says Paul Cohen, 60, who recently retired as Hillel’s consultant for Northern California campuses.

The National Union of Jewish Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Intersexual, Queer and Questioning Students (NUJLS), founded in 1998, is America’s largest organization dedicated to serving and empowering Jewish LGBT students and young adults.  In May 2007, NUJLS hired its first full-time paid executive director, Vanessa “Vinny” Prell.  The position was made possible by a grant from the Charles and Lynn Schusterman Family Foundation

“My role [as NUJLS executive director] is to provide education, outreach, empowerment and support for LGBT students,” says Prell, a 2005 graduate of the University of California, Santa Barbara. “And also to work with people who work with LGBT students to create an environment that is positive and welcoming and celebratory of LGBT Jews.”

Every year NUJLS holds an annual conference on a different college campus.  Students of diverse sexual and gender identities and diverse religious backgrounds create a supportive community and learn about issues pertaining to both their Jewish and LGBT identities. Prell says 750 students have attended a conference since 1997.

American University senior Michael Weinberger had been “out” as a gay Jew since high school. And while he served as the Shabbat chair at American University Hillel, his first NUJLS conference proved to be an emotional experience.

“I had a very emotional reaction during the Havdalah circle,” says Weinberger. “I thought I’d conquered all the issues of being both gay and Jewish, but being surrounded by other students who were also experiencing the same thing, I thought ‘Wow, this isn’t just my experience, I’m part of a community.’”

Creating community was the impetus for Rabbi Mychal Copeland of Stanford University Hillel and formerly of UCLA Hillel to help a small group of Jewish LGBT students start “Mishpacha.” Eventually the group became a registered campus organization and a member of UCLA’s Queer Alliance.  The students organized Shabbat dinners, held movie screenings and even staged a partially-drag Purim shpiel.

“It’s also an engagement tool,” says Copeland. “There are students out there who identify as LGBT and don’t know that their Jewish identity can be meshed with that new identity that they are exploring.  Or they come from backgrounds where it was a definite no.”
 
Razi Zarchy, 23, one of the four students who started Mishpacha at UCLA, says his involvement with the Hillel-supported group allowed him to “go and take up space in Hillel and not feel like an outsider.” 

To help other Hillel professionals help Jewish LGBT students not feel like outsiders, two Jewish Campus Service Corps fellows launched the development of a resource guide in December 2006.  Set to be released in time for the 2007-2008 academic year, the guide consists of LGBT history and vocabulary as well as information on “Being an Ally,” “Psychological, Emotional and Spiritual Issues of Coming Out,” “Jewish Response to Homophobia” and “Affirming Jewish Text Studies.”  

“Even doing something as simple as making bathrooms gender-neutral can go a long way in making a Hillel building a more welcoming space for transgender students,” explains Rachel Singer, senior Jewish Campus Service Corps fellow at the University of Chicago and one of the resource guide developers.
 
“Many LGBT students grew up in synagogues where they read Leviticus on Yom Kippur and after hearing that your identity is an 'abomination', for some students they are comforted to know that there is a gay Jewish community,” says Copeland. “And that’s a lot, to know they’re not the first to ever experience this conflict.”



Share:

DIGG Page.  Digg | Delicious Page.  del.icio.us | Reddit Page.  Reddit | Facebook Page.  Facebook | Twitter.  Twitter



Comments:
Posted By: Anonymous on 5/19/2007 5:01:00 PM

Suzanne,

Thanks for highlighting the opportunities we have in Hillel to maintain an open tent and welcoming environment for tudents with multiple identities.

Paul
Posted By: Doreen on 5/20/2007 2:44:00 PM

How wonderful that young LGBT Jews are now accepted in the community! 

How sad for the one's that hate!

Posted By: Arthur on 5/20/2007 8:14:00 PM

While I am happy to learn that Hillel is helping students with a strong gay identity maintain their Jewishness, I believe Hillel needs to also help those with unwanted same sex attractions learn about organizations such as JONAH which helps those desirous of changing their sexual orientation to do so. Freedom of choice and lack of viewpoint discrimination are important elements of college education.
Posted By: Steve on 5/20/2007 9:28:00 PM

Why does disagreement make you a "hater"?  Are you also a hater if you think incest is wrong?   Let's say that you even agree that the Torah's condemnation of homosexuality has been misunderstood or reinterpreted; how then do you justify bisexuality and transgender which are explicitly forbidden?  I don't get the lumping together of every sexual variety.
Posted By: Vanessa on 5/21/2007 3:16:00 PM

Thank you!  It's lovely to see the queer Jewish community portrayed in a positive light.
Posted By: Z on 5/21/2007 9:29:00 PM

Thank you for such a great article.  It's really encouraging to see something so positive being put out there by such a widespread organization as Hillel.
Posted By: Jonathan on 5/21/2007 9:56:00 PM

Steve, who said anything about disagreement being hate? Are there not people who genuinely hate out there? Why do you assume that decrying hate is code for opposing simple disagreement? One who assumes that another believes all disagreement is hate is likely telling a great deal about whether he disagrees or hates.
Posted By: Justin on 5/22/2007 11:55:00 AM

The problem with organizations that advocate changing your sexuality is that they are based on the false (and dangerous) tenets that you can do so.  Reputable studies show that what follows is psychological, sexual, and emotional drama--in most if not all the cases.  Acceptance and inclusion cannot include such a plan because it undermines creating a positive experience for gay and lesbian Jews.  We need to reenforce self-awareness and fulfillment, not religious self-loathing. 
Posted By: Nathan on 5/22/2007 1:48:00 PM

What Hillel is doing is absolutely disgusting. It is one thing not to want to force a halakhic framework upon students, but it is another to deliverately promote homosexuality as a kosher way of life. The Tora is clear on the matter of homosexual relations (which are punishable by death). Lesbianism is also forbidden as a gentile practice (see Maimonides' Sefer Ha-Misvot on this).
Posted By: Nathan on 5/22/2007 2:09:00 PM

I would like to encourage students to write letters of protest to Hillel's directors regarding this matter. We as a people were given a certain law, and were commanded to follow it, without turning right or left. What Hillel is doing is to try to convey the idea that we can twist the law to accommodate it to our own whims, based on delusions and imaginary desires. This is not rationialism, but its anti-thesis.
Posted By: Leora on 5/22/2007 4:17:00 PM

I am so proud of Hillel for what they are doing for the LGBTQ community! I am saddened that someone like Nathan felt the need to share their hatered on this lovely issue. I say that it is about time that there was something legitimate on campus for these students and I am very proud to be a part of what is happening!
Posted By: Ahuva on 5/22/2007 6:17:00 PM

The Torah is also clear on the matter of a mother providing a lamb, pigeon, and turtledove as ritual sacrifices after giving birth.  (See Leviticus 12:6)  We don’t follow that rule anymore; Judaism has changed.  After the Temple was destroyed, we as Jews had to reexamine our religion in light of the new reality and find a Jewish lifestyle that spoke to our changing spiritual needs.
Posted By: Ahuva on 5/22/2007 6:17:00 PM

In recent times, our misunderstandings of homosexuality are being “destroyed” by scientific research, so we, like our ancestors, must also reexamine our religion in light of the new reality regarding homosexuality.
Posted By: Ahuva on 5/22/2007 6:19:00 PM

Also, Hillel is not promoting homosexuality as a lifestyle for Jewish heterosexuals to adopt.  Hillel is simply living up to its pluralistic standards and embracing all sorts of Jews, including gay Jews. Heaven forbid that we should embrace all kinds of Jews!  That IS absolutely disgusting, isn’t it?
Posted By: Jacob on 5/22/2007 9:46:00 PM

I graduated from the University of Oklahoma where I was an active member of the Hillel organisation on campus.  I was lucky to surrounded by a group of welcoming, accepting and non-biassed individuals.  Hillel has always been an inspiration to me and continues to make me so proud to be  a gay Jewish man today.
Posted By: Yoshi on 5/22/2007 11:56:00 PM

Go to www.youtube.com and do a search for "west wing gay"  The first video links to a short clip called 'Think Homosexuality is "wrong?' from the T.V. series The West Wing and is a very intelligent and relevant video to the debate on this comment board.
Posted By: Mike on 5/23/2007 2:31:00 PM

I think its great that, even virtually, Hillel provides us with a forum to come together and discuss these matters.
Posted By: Josh on 5/24/2007 3:42:00 PM

Hillel once again has lived up to its creed of being pluralistic and accepting save for the traditional community. Hillel has once again proven that it's doors are closed for traditionalists and for growing Jews. They have sent a clear and resounding message: "We are anti-tradition, and we will do whatever we can to make you traditionalists feel unwelcome here."
Posted By: Josh on 5/24/2007 3:43:00 PM

There are so many traditionalist inclusive organizations that accapt all kinds of Jews regardless of orientation, but they dare not sanction individual actions regardless if it means consuming non-kosher, or living an alternative lifestyle. Hillel has gone to far.
Posted By: Anonymous on 5/24/2007 8:04:00 PM

Josh, how exactly does accepting individuals with alternative lifestyles demonstrate that Hillel's doors are closed to traditionalists?
Posted By: Tom on 5/25/2007 12:42:00 AM

Why does Hillel need to make special groups for people with alternative sexual lifestyles? Why can't Hillel just treat all Jewish students as equals? How would the LGBT community feel if Hillel promoted a heterosexual based Jewish group on campus? I think the double standard is lost on a lot in support of this.
Posted By: Tom on 5/25/2007 12:51:00 AM

I find it disheartening that Hillel is supporting something that is blatently forbidden in Torah. How would it look it Hillel started a club for not observing-Shabbat or a pork eating club? Hillel should take a hint from Chabad who has programs that are extremely popular with students (even LGBT ones) while still adhering to the our Torah.
Posted By: Jeff on 5/25/2007 1:03:00 AM

Hillel has sunk to a new low.  Homosexuality is the one thing in the Torah called an abomination.

Hillel is no longer a jewish organization, but a G-dless liberal secular one.
Posted By: Anonymous on 5/25/2007 10:57:00 AM

Why, Tom, is it necessary for Hillel to start groups for students with alternative lifestyles?  Probably because people like yourself make LGBTQ students feel excluded from the Jewish community on campus.
Posted By: Nathan on 5/27/2007 5:44:00 PM

After the destruction of the Temple, the halakha did not change. The only thing that changed are the conditions. Since we no longer have a Temple, we can no longer bring sacrifices until we rebuild it (may we be blessed to do it in our days!). However, the halakha is still the same, and the mother is still liable for the offerings (Lev. 12:6), only that she has to wait until the Temple is rebuilt.
Posted By: Nathan on 5/27/2007 5:49:00 PM

What is the purpose of remaining a Jew if you are going to live by your own undertanding of right and wrong, in lieu of the Torah? I have a hard time understanding these people. They go by their own feelings of right and wrong (bishrirut libbam) as King David mentions in one of his Psalms. They don't care about the Torah's continuous warnings. Everyday when we read shema`, we are reminded about this warning, but nobody cares to listen . . .
Posted By: Anonymous on 5/29/2007 12:29:00 AM

Nathan, to answer your question, people identify as Jewish in many different ways, not all of them religious.  One may also feel culturally or spiritually Jewish, and these are most certainly acceptable identifications as well.
Posted By: Yossie on 5/29/2007 9:57:00 AM

The word "abomination," which is applied to homosexuality, appears 122 times in the Torah, including for such behavior as eating certain non-kosher foods (Deut. 14:3) and for a wife remarrying her first husband after she has been married to someone else in the interim (24:4).  King Solomon in Proverbs adds the following statement that one ought to reflect upon when seeking to discredit or delegitimatize a segment of our people: "He that sows discord among brethren" is an abomination.
Posted By: Anonymous on 5/29/2007 9:45:00 PM

Well said, Yossie.
Posted By: Clara on 5/30/2007 11:18:00 AM

Pirke Avot 1:6 says, "judge all people humbly."  Our greatest challenge as Jews and human beings is to resist the urge to force our morals onto every Jew.  To grapple with Torah is the responsibility of every Jew - traditional or not (perhaps that explains the old joke "1 Jew, 10 opinions").  Judaism is unique in that each Jew has an individual relationship with God, so Hillel can go on accepting all Jews, and the rest is between the individual and God.
Posted By: Danielle on 5/30/2007 5:37:00 PM

Judaism needs to be Pluralistic and accepting all Jews regardless of Sexual Orientation. If certain Jews don't feel that they have a safe place within Judaism (or within Hillel) what is the incentive to stay Jewish or in Hillel? 
"Ahavas Yisrael" to love your fellow Jew is something that I hope people keep in mind and is something Hillel practices by opening its doors to more than just the straight community. 
Posted By: Jack on 5/31/2007 7:15:00 PM

If only...If only there had been an organization like NUJLS when I went to college. I would not have felt cast out in the diaspora, separate from K'lal Yisrael thanks to people like Nathan, Tom, Jeff and Josh. Thank you Hillel for this article. About me now - I found a home, a synagogue founded over 30 years ago by GLBT Jews.
Posted By: ronit on 5/16/2008 5:19:00 PM

Queer and Jewish = twice blessed!  Mazel tov to Hillel for finally catching up.  Now, what do we have to do to make room again for a critique of Zionism
in our Jewish communities?
Posted By: moshe kaufman on 11/25/2009 2:07:00 AM

I am jewish and bisexual and i am so happy to see this kind of improvment in our community!To those of you that think we are disgusting or that our "sinful lifestyle" is so bad than let me ask you a question: should we kill anyone that does not keep shabbat ?because i gurantee the majority of hillel do not observe shabbat according to orthodox standards. 


Post Public Comment:

RE: Being Jewish and LGBT on Campus

Name (will be displayed if comment is posted):

Your E-mail (will not be displayed): * Required Field

 

Public Comments (up to 500 characters): * Required Field 


 


spacer alignment. spacer alignment.
Content area dropshadow.
spacer alignment.