Hillel: The Foundation for Jewish Campus Life - Logo and Link Home.
Search:     
navigation bar dropshadow.
spacer alignment.
spacer alignment.
Getting Tested: Why College Jews Need To Know Now
February 21, 2008
Comments (20) | Add | E-mail this to a friend


Freshman year, Shoshana Rosen took a test that determined her future.

While working as a camp counselor in Pennsylvania, Rosen participated in a genetic screening program run by the Victor Center for Jewish Genetic Diseases in Philadelphia. The test revealed that Rosen carries the gene for Cystic Fibrosis (CF), an inherited chronic disease that affects the lungs and digestive system of about 30,000 people in the United States. CF is one of many fatal genetic diseases prevalent among Ashkenazi Jews (Jews of Eastern European descent).

Jonathan Finger and Shoshana Rosen.
Jonathan Finger and Shoshana Rosen.

As a carrier, Rosen has a 25 percent chance of producing an affected baby if her future husband is also a carrier for CF. Rosen's plans to marry Jewish put her at an increased risk for passing on the genetic disorder.

That's because 1 in 4 Ashkenazi Jews is a carrier for a Jewish genetic disease which could be as treatable as Gaucher's Disease Type 1 or as devastating as Tay-Sachs Disease for which there is no cure. Babies born with Tay-Sachs usually die before the age of 5. Without prior screening, young couples run the risk of being genetically incompatible and facing heartbreaking consequences.

When Rosen learned all this, she took the cause of genetic testing awareness to heart and in 2006, her senior year at the University of Pittsburgh, she brought the Victor Center to campus to educate students about Jewish genetic diseases. Nearly 200 young people, including Rosen's boyfriend, received genetic counseling and were screened for nine different diseases free of charge. Rosen's boyfriend tested negative for the CF gene.

Rosen is now 24 years old and working as the youth director at a Reform temple in Delaware. She and her college boyfriend, Jonathan Finger, are still dating and can consider marriage free of fear from transmitting CF to their children.

Genetic chart.
Genetic chart.

"The good thing about getting testing young is that it's of such low consequence," says Rosen. "What about couples who get tested when they are already engaged? What do they do then?"

Dr. Adele Schneider, clinical director of genetics at the Victor Center says that promoting awareness early about Jewish genetic diseases is the first step toward eradicating them. She's worked with many Hillels to sponsor genetic counseling sessions for Jewish students on campus. Penn Hillel hosted the Victor Center for a cross-campus genetic screening for Jewish students from University of Pennsylvania as well as nearby Temple University and Drexel University. Awareness campaigns by several Jewish organizations have also been launched at schools in New York, Arizona, California and Massachusetts. And Yeshiva University offers screening for its students through Dor Yeshorim, an anonymous testing program developed by an Orthodox rabbi in the 1980s.

While instances of Jewish genetic diseases have declined significantly since the Jewish community first embraced screening in the 1970s, there still remains a great lack of awareness within the Jewish community according to Michelle Gilats, genetic counselor for Children's Memorial and the Chicago Center for Jewish Genetic Disorders.

"We want young people to know that this opportunity [for early screening] exists," explains Gilats.

In Illinois, the Chicago Center offers four screenings per year, which include a dinner presentation, for just $90. Gilats explains that cost is far below the thousands of dollars some laboratories charge for genetic testing, which many insurance companies will not cover unless an individual is pregnant or thinking of becoming pregnant. The screenings also help to educate the community about how Jewish genetic disorders are inherited and why they exist.

"Judaism is not just a religion, but an ethnic background," says Gilats. "All ethnic groups have higher rates of different illnesses."

Because Ashkenazi Jews were an isolated population for nearly 1,000 years, tending to marry among each other with little migration in or out, genes mutated at a higher rate. The result is higher concentrations of certain diseases and disorders within Ashkenazi ancestry.         

Robin Fiddle Posnack and her family have been struggling with one Jewish genetic disease for more than two years. Posnack's son, Jack, was the 601st child to be diagnosed with the Jewish genetic disease Familial Dysautonomia (FD), also known as Riley-Day disease, in February 2006. Posnack, already a mother to a healthy son from a previous marriage, told a Westchester County, New York, newspaper that her doctor didn't screen for FD when she became pregnant again by her second husband in 2005. A blood test for FD had been developed four years earlier. As it turns out, both Posnack and her identical twin sister Mandy are carriers. Neither one had any idea until Jack started showing symptoms at birth. Posnack noticed that her son did not shed tears, not even during his bris (ritual circumcision). A barrage of tests over the next eight weeks revealed the devastating news.

Avi Buchbinder and Leah Metz.
Avi Buchbinder and Leah Metz.

Children with FD are lacking a vital protein that affects the sensory and nervous systems. Without that protein, basic functions such as swallowing and breathing are a struggle. FD patients, like Jack, cannot regulate their own body temperature and blood pressure, something a healthy person does automatically. Jack also feels no pain, which makes him vulnerable to a host of other health issues. The good news is that new research has found babies diagnosed in 2006 (as Jack was) have a 50% chance of living to age 40 (the average lifespan for an FD patient is 15 years).

Leah Metz, 23, and Avi Buchbinder, 24, want to avoid the pain Jack's family has endured. The couple will be married this summer and underwent genetic counseling in December at the urging of a friend through the Chicago Center.

Because Metz, a agraduate of UC Irvine and Buchbinder, a Northwestern University graduate student, are of Ashkenazi descent (though Metz's mother converted to Judaism) there was some concern about the health of their future children. To their relief, bloodwork on Buchbinder determined he is not a carrier for any genetic diseases and so even if Metz is, there is no risk of producing an affected child together.

"We wanted to be prepared so that we don't have to worry when we're ready to have children," says Metz.      
                    
Read about the ethics of genetic screening in Learn Something Jewish

For more news like this and up-to-date briefs about Jewish campus life, subscribe to our free eNewsletter Hillel Campus Report.



Share:

DIGG Page.  Digg | Delicious Page.  del.icio.us | Reddit Page.  Reddit | Facebook Page.  Facebook | Twitter.  Twitter



Comments:
Posted By: Reuven on 2/21/2008 8:13:00 PM

One small (but common) factual inaccuracy that I know about because of taking evolution: it's not that Jewish genes mutated faster than the general population, it's just that selective endogamous mating lowered the effective population size of Ashkenazi Jews, causing mutant disease alleles to accrue/become more noticeable in the gene pool faster.
Posted By: Yoni P on 2/21/2008 9:30:00 PM

An informative article about genetic disorders and the universities that have offered screening programs. The article is severely lacking any information for people who attend one of the hundreds of other universities or cities around the nation and want to be tested.
Posted By: Rishona (genetic counseling student) on 2/21/2008 10:54:00 PM

I think raising awareness & providing education about genetic testing is great. I think an individual's choice NOT to be tested, or to wait, should be explored. The article suggests testing is of “low consequence." There aren’t health consequences for a carrier, but results may impact who one dates or cause unforeseen stress when choosing spouse. I advocate testing pre-pregnancy, but information should be provided in a way that allows individuals to explore all possible implications.
Posted By: David on 2/22/2008 2:29:00 AM

This is a great article and people should be tested for genetic differences that could cause issues for children.  But be careful when testing for genetic variations that can effect you (like breast cancer).  Such findings can impact your health insurance and are reason for coverage to be dropped.
Posted By: Andie on 2/22/2008 6:26:00 AM

Tay Sachs testing  is carried out in England, and Jewish Care  with the assistance of Guys Hospital, who carry out the testing, and volunteer phlebotomists and doctors regularly go into  high schools and screen young people aged 17 and over, Jewish Care also carry out screening sessions for those not at school.

Posted By: Dana on 2/22/2008 9:32:00 AM

I agree with Yoni...I'd like to be tested but where do I go?  To whom do I speak?  The article touches the surface of the issue, but does not invite further personal exploration into our genetics.
Posted By: Susan on 2/22/2008 9:42:00 AM

I know you're all trying to be delicate, but all of the options need to be spelled out clearly.  Some couples who are both carriers may choose to adopt.  Others may choose to end a pregnancy if a fetus tests positive for a devastating genetic disorder.  I don't think you narrow the already limited jewish dating pool by prescreening all jewish teens and advising them not to date other carriers.  Educate, and tell them all the possibilities.
Posted By: Mike R. on 2/22/2008 12:00:00 PM

A valuable article that needs to be distributed widely.  I lost my son to Familial Dysautonomia, now the most common of the fatal Jewish genetic diseases.  Every Jew of child-bearing age should be tested, because 1 in 25 is a carrier.  For more information on this particular disease, go to www.fdhope.org, an organization funding research on the disease.
Posted By: mere on 2/22/2008 12:13:00 PM

Does anyone know where you can get tested for a low cost?  I live in New York and have been aware of this issue since a was a kid.  It is imperative to keep the jewish faith alive and marry other jews. But testing is not cheap and insurance doesn't cover it... help!
Posted By: Danielle Freni on 2/22/2008 12:27:00 PM

In New York City - Montefiore, Mt. Sinai and NYU Medical Center all do genetic screening. You can also search for screening centers by state/country at this web site:
http://www.canavanfoundation.org/directory.php

If you still don't find the information you need, please email me at dfreni@hillel.org
Posted By: Brian Cohen on 2/22/2008 12:53:00 PM

Very important article about a very serious issue.  Thank you for posting.  Insurance wouldn't cover my genetic testing even though I have a family history of FD.  Although I would have been willing to spend the money to get tested, I was able to get free testing when I visited Philadelphia at a Jewish community fair.
Posted By: Lara on 2/22/2008 1:45:00 PM

My concern lies in the protection of my studetns with such concerns. I think testing is very useful, however, what concerns me more than the cost issue is the ownership of the information. Family history can be enough of a liability in the hands of insurance companies. Should we let them have the test results? More needs to be done to make this safe medically and financially.
Posted By: B. Kauffman on 2/22/2008 4:28:00 PM

Excellent article. My cousin learned she was a Tay Sachs Carrier 20 weeks into a pregnacy. Her husband was not;But it reinforces the need to be proactive. My husband's sibling died of FD. When pregnant it was stressful not having an available carrier test. I wish the other tests were available . Our younger cousins have been tested. It would not have changed my choice of partners. What it does offer is making a choice. Thanks for what you are doing for our students.
Posted By: Marion Yanovsky on 2/24/2008 6:40:00 AM

Free carrier screening for Jewish genetic diseases will be available to college students in Westchester County, NY in the fall of 2008 sponsored by the Jewish Genetic Disease Consortium (JGDC). 
Information will soon be available at www.jewishgeneticdiseases.org    Carrier screening laboratory locations in the New York Area can be found on the NTSAD NY Area website 
www./ntsad-ny.org/screening.html  or nationwide at www.ntsad.org.  
Posted By: Anonymous on 2/24/2008 6:24:00 PM

Why doesn't this talk about Crohns/Colitis?  It's becoming such a common disease in Ashkenazi Jews. Some people don't even know what Crohns and Colitis are...that is very unfortunate...More education needs to happen.
Posted By: Anonymous on 2/25/2008 1:55:00 AM

There is no genetic testing for Crohns or Colitis, so that may be a reason for its omission.
Posted By: Wendy on 2/27/2008 12:01:00 PM

What about Jewish young adults who already have cystic fibrosis? How can this affect their relationships? The "best child" possibe would still be a carrier. Would he/she be stigmatized down the road? Why don't we strive harder for a cure instead? Are we trying to create a "pure race" with all this screening and consciousness? I urge Hillel & the Jewish community to proceed with extreme caution until they have considered all sides.
Posted By: Marcia Neeley on 3/3/2008 10:01:00 AM

1 in 40 Ashkenazi Jewish women carry a mutated breast cancer gene. Genetic testing can help determine the course of action you can take to reduce the risk. Sharsheret, a national org. for young Jewish women with breast cancer, offers a genetics program. To speak with a Sharsheret Genetic Counselor, call 866-474-2774 or emailinfo@sharsheret.org.
Posted By: Lucy on 3/11/2008 2:54:00 AM

I completely agree with Wendy's comment from 2/27/08. My mother is an Ashkenazi Jew--my father is Roman Catholic--and I am the first person in my family to be diagnosed with CF. I have thought a lot about this topic, as I would not want my child to have to have CF, or any other disease. However, research is at a point where cures and treatments are within reach. As Wendy said, let's focus on raising funds to research, treat, and cure these diseases.
Posted By: Malka on 8/19/2008 2:41:00 PM

If anyone from the NY area is looking to bring carrier screening to their campus please e-mail me at malka.sasson@nyumc.org NYU Medical center is looking to offer screening services on college campuses, they even provide a session with a genetic counselor. 1 out of every 4 Jews is a carrier, get tested today!


Post Public Comment:

RE: Getting Tested: Why College Jews Need To Know Now

Name (will be displayed if comment is posted):

Your E-mail (will not be displayed): * Required Field

 

Public Comments (up to 500 characters): * Required Field 


 


spacer alignment. spacer alignment.
Content area dropshadow.
spacer alignment.